Thoughts? Advice? Email it to

My girlfriend broke up with me this past Sunday, 2 days after Valentine’s Day.  Now I’m wondering if I have the right to ask her to give me back the watch I got her for Valentine’s Day.  It cost me $200 bucks and I’m not a rich guy. My sister says I'll look like a jerk. You can call me cheap, but she shouldn't of accepted such an expensive gift if she didn't even have feelings for me.